Icarus Theatre continues to challenge audiences with bold material that raises difficult questions.
Its latest production, Liliana Padilla’s How to Defend Yourself!, at The Theatre Centre’s Incubator Space, revisits campus issues surrounding sexual assault, consent and the complicated relationships between young women and men. More than four decades after an earlier generation experienced these challenges, they remain pressing concerns.
Emily Anne Corcoran and Erik Richards transform the Incubator Space into a functional gymnasium and self-defence training environment, making effective use of the three-quarter staging. The arrangement generally provides good sightlines, although the final video sequence was difficult to see from my aisle seat.
Brandi (Kaeley Jade Wiebe) leads a self-defence class organized in response to the recent sexual assault of the unseen Susannah at a frat party, a friend of the girls in the class. As the female students learn to fend off attackers and avoid victimization, the women must begin to confront their own internal rages, anxieties, trauma, confusion, and desires.
Adding to the tension of what the girls experience, two boys have joined the workshop: Andy (Anthony Goncharov) and Eggo (Samel Sunil). Their presence complicates the workshop’s atmosphere, exposing the differences between how young men understand their behaviour and how young women experience it.
How to Defend Yourself! won the Yale Drama Series Prize. Yet Padilla’s play is not without controversy. The students remain concerned about the unseen Susannah and her well-being, yet their conversations frequently turn sexually explicit as they discuss the boys they desire or have dated. This juxtaposition adds an uncomfortable dimension to a workshop intended to address sexual assault and personal safety.
Icarus’s production demonstrates the qualities that earned Padilla’s script its recognition.
Emily Anne Corcoran directs with gritty determination, allowing Padilla’s raw, unfiltered language to retain its force. Her direction keeps the seven performers focused on the difficult material without softening its confrontational edges. Whether one likes that kind of language used is not the point – it is the language spoken by young people when they gather together, and it doesn’t matter whether they’re young boys or young women.
The seven-member ensemble sustains the production’s escalating tension, although the performers occasionally mistake vocal intensity for emotional depth.
Kaeley Jade Wiebe’s Brandi (the self-defence class leader) is worldly and confident. She’s aware of the horrible treatment of women on campus and isn’t afraid to confront it when necessary. Paula Goldie’s Diana projects considerable bravado, using her sexual confidence as a protective front. Anthony Goncharov’s Andy is smarmy, while his pal Eggo (Samel Sunil) struggles to understand consent, particularly when his interpretation of an encounter differs from the woman’s.
It may have been opening-night jitters, but a few scenes rely on sustained screaming and shouting to convey emotional distress. While the subject matter warrants intensity, the repeated vocal outbursts eventually become exhausting and risk diminishing the dramatic impact. Greater attention to listening, pacing and emotional modulation would allow the performers to create more convincing peaks and valleys.
How to Defend Yourself! is recommended for its willingness to confront difficult questions about consent, sexual violence and the complexities of young adult relationships. Despite occasional excesses in vocal delivery, Padilla’s play offers considerable material for discussion. An audience talkback during the remaining performances would be particularly worthwhile. As performances continue, I have every confidence the shouting will be controlled.
Running time: approximately 100 minutes with no interval/intermission.
The production runs to November 28 in the Incubator Space at The Theatre Centre, 1115 Queen Street West, Toronto. For tickets: https://theatrecentre.org/event/how-to-defend-yourself/ or call (416) 538-0988
ICARUS THEATRE presents
How To Defend Yourself by Liliana Padilla
Directed by Emily Anne Corcoran
Set, Costume and Props: Emily Anne Corcoran
Lighting Designer: Lilian Adom
Sound and Set Designer/Production Manager: Erik Richards
Stage Manager: Kayleigh Munday
Producer: Anthony Goncharov
Performers: Parastoo Amanzadeh, Paula Goldie, Kaeley Jade Wiebe, Donnon Root, Sasha Khan, Anthony Goncharov, Samel Sunil












