Ann-Marie MacDonald leads a spirited production that turns Shakespearean tragedy upside down while exploring women’s identity, ambition and intellectual independence.
Ann-Marie MacDonald’s academic comedy is a witty, audacious exploration of women’s identity, ambition and the power to rewrite their own destinies.
Now on stage at Canadian Stage’s Bluma Appel Theatre, it’s the story of overlooked (and perhaps overworked) Queen’s University professor Constance Ledbelly (the wonderful Ann Marie MacDonald), whose academic research finds that Othello and Romeo and Juliet were comedies rather than tragedies. Constance has discovered that if a wise fool were reinstated into the plays, they could no longer be tragedies. Despite her discovery, Constance lacks the confidence to present her research to her superior, Claude Night (Carolyn Taylor). Her journey into the worlds of Shakespeare’s plays becomes an opportunity to confront her own insecurities and reconsider her place in the academic world.
What makes this story even more outlandishly attractive? Constance meets with Desdemona (Jessica B. Hill) and Juliet (Caroline Toal), who will help the young professor find the lost fool. Two extremely important props from both stories take centre stage in discovering the lost fool
Judith Bowden’s enormous academic office set immediately commands attention. Sitting before this gargantuan structure, I couldn’t help recalling the familiar words from CBC’s The Friendly Giant: “Look up, waaayyyy up.” And that is precisely what I did, studying the peeling paint on this gargantuan academic set before me. Bowden also handles the costume design, and, again, the Elizabethan look from long ago is aptly captured in some quick costume changes. Jason Hand’s lighting remains shadowy and angular, creating intensity and tension.
Alisa Palmer directs with curiosity and wonder. Hearing why Constance believes the two plays are comedies rather than tragedies made me want to return to the text and see the plot unfold again.
The cast is terrific.
This is my first time watching MacDonald as Constance, so I cannot draw on seeing her play the role twenty-five years earlier. MacDonald is witty, intelligent, daring, sharp, and quite agile, especially given how much running she has to do, and the play runs two hours and thirty minutes. It’s always nice to see Jessica B. Hill’s work on stage. Her Desdemona is brave. Caroline Toal’s Juliet is daring and audacious.
What still seems to work on a comedic level in the twenty-first century is the cross-dressing dramatic technique. Seeing Praneet Akilla’s Romeo dressed as a woman and Caroline Toal’s dressed as a man is still hilarious.
The production closes November 22 – two days left.
November has been a busy time at the theatre, and I didn’t get a chance to see the show until late.
With the production closing November 22, only two performances remain. Canadian Stage audiences have a worthwhile opportunity to experience MacDonald’s clever, irreverent reimagining of Shakespeare, anchored by Ann-Marie MacDonald’s engaging performance. It is an entertaining reminder that sometimes the best way to understand a tragedy is to imagine it as a comedy.
Running time: approximately two hours and ten minutes with one intermission.
Full cast and show credits: https://www.canadianstage.com/shows-events/season/goodnight-desdemona-good-morning-juliet.













